Uninterruptible Power Supplies (UPS)
See model ratings below. Also see standalone inverters.
WHAT DOES A UPS DO?: An uninterruptible power supply (UPS)
is a battery powered inverter that supplies AC voltage for a short period of
time when the main power fails or flickers. A UPS is used between a computer
& the wall plug, when computer information could be lost if power is lost,
or where improper shutdown might cause data corruption if there was a sudden
power loss. A UPS often will also filter the line Voltage for spikes that could
cause damage to computer components, but most UPS's only have limited line filtering
capabilities, so you might want to also use a really good power bar with excellent
surge protection of 2000 Joules or more. Some UPS's will also bump up the Voltage
(Automatic Voltage Regulation) when it is too low (called a "brown out"),
or cut back on Voltage level if it is too high, but the less expensive units
don't usually do this function very well. In North America the typical level
is 117 AC Volts at 60 Hz cycles & in Europe it is 220 AC Volts at 50 Hz
cycles. Most computer power supplies are designed to accept a wide range of
input Voltages (often 100 - 240), but if the Voltage falls outside that range,
weird computer malfunctions can occur. I recommend the use of a half decent
UPS for your computer & monitor for many business applications were power
failures could cost big bucks & especially for professional video editing
computer applications where hours worth of rendering could be ruined by a 3
second power interruption.
HOW LARGE SHOULD A UPS BE?: It is quite important to choose
a UPS that is large enough (larger is better). As a minimum the UPS must be
able to support your computer & monitor for several minutes, which gives
you time to save files & close down the computer properly, or allows the
software to do this for you (through the RS-232 serial port connection if the
UPS comes equip for auto shutdown). UPS's have a VA size rating. Usually VA
means "Volts times Amps" which is Watts, but in the case of a UPS
the VA rating does not mean that this is how many Watts the UPS can sustain.
Often the UPS literature will indicate that the actual maximum Wattage handling
capabilities is about 50-60% the VA rating, but my experience is that on smaller
UPS's it's even lower than that. For example, the CyberPower 650SL mentioned
below is rated to be able to handle 350 Watts, but if you were to plug a 225
Watt device into this fully charged 650VA UPS (rated for 350 Watts) & unplug
the UPS from the wall, the power from the UPS to the 225 Watt device would shut
off immediately. Only when I lowered the device load to 175 Watts was the UPS
able to sustain the load for a period of time. So for smaller UPS's in the 650VA
range & lower, it is probably a good idea not to expect to get reliable
coverage if your Wattage is higher than 25% of the VA rating (i.e. 650VA should
handle 163 Watts). When using a UPS for a new computer & large monitor,
I would recommend a minimum 700 VA rating or larger if you can afford it.
TYPICAL COMPUTER & MONITOR WATTAGES: A small computer
with 1 hard drive might draw as little as 60 Watts when idle & a dual Pentium
Zeon 2.4 GHz computer might draw about 135 Watts when idle & both will draw
plenty more when in heavy duty use. A 19" CRT tube computer monitor might
typically draw about 93 Watts, a 17" CRT monitor about 70 Watts & an
18" LCD flat panel monitor typically about 43 Watts. If you estimate the
total idle Wattage of your computer & monitor, then multiply by 4, that
will give you the minimum VA rating you should use for the UPS in your computer
setup. If you can afford to buy a larger UPS, do so because the ability of the
batteries to handle the load diminishes over the years as the batteries age.
You can expect to get 6-7 years from the rechargeable batteries of a UPS if
treated properly & the batteries are not left in a discharged condition
for many hours after a power failure. The batteries use gel
lead acid technology which is similar to the battery in your car
& they must always be recharged right away if you expect long life from
them.
TEST THE UPS: After you buy a UPS & before you plug the
auto shut down serial cable into your computer, charge the UPS for at least
8 hours, then plug your computer & monitor into the UPS with the UPS still
plugged into the wall outlet, boot the computer but don't open any applications
& wait at least 3 minutes for things to stabilize. Unplug the UPS from the
wall & time how long the UPS can supply power before it shuts off. Do not
use the applications in the computer while doing this test. This will give you
the maximum time your UPS can support the computer & monitor under the most
ideal conditions. If this is acceptable to you, install the RS-232 serial cable
& UPS software & set the automatic shutdown time for 1/2 or less of
the time you just got under ideal conditions. If you add other devices to draw
power from the UPS, redo this test. Once a year repeat this test & adjust
auto shutdown time accordingly.
American Power Conversion
APC XS 1000 (BX1000), has a 1000VA or 600 Watt rating
Although the box & user manual mention that this unit has surge
protection, nowhere does it mention how much surge protection, so
I will make an assumption that it is minimal.. The spike filtering
protection is 825 Joules & the maximum surge current is 36,000
Amps. It has 6 electrical outlets that are battery protected (spaced
far enough apart to accommodate some mole transformer blocks), 2
electrical outlets & a phone/DSL/modem/fax port that are surge
protected only. There is a ground fault test light built in. Comes
with a data port connection, USB to RJ-45 cable & software in
case you prefer to install the automatic shut down software (not
tested). The box says that the "on battery Voltage" should
be 115 VAC + or - 8% (i.e. 105.8 - 124.2 VAC when wall power is
out & UPS is driven from the battery) however it did not comply
with this range except during the last several minutes of power.
The box says that the Automatic Voltage Regulation (AVR) increases
on-line Voltage by 12% when utility Voltage is 94 - 107 Volts. I
test this & found that .... This unit does not seem to have
very good AVR (Automatic Voltage Regulator) despite it's advertised
claims. It mentions on the box that it protects in brownout situations
(under 112 Volts) (which means that it should prop up the low line
Voltage & bring it back up near nominal 117 VAC levels) &
overvoltage situations (over 130 Volts). I tested brownout conditions
with a stepping transformer & this UPS did not kick in when
it should & prop up the Voltage until it got quite low (didn't
cut in at 107.5 Volts, but did prop up Voltage when the input was
at 102.8 Volts) (it's suppose to kick in when Voltage goes below
112 VAC). When I tested this UPS 1 minute after unplugged from the
wall under a 100 Watt load (light bulb), the Voltage level
dropped to about 101.5 Volts. (unacceptable). which isn't
adequate in my opinion for many devices & certainly not what
I would have expected for a unit that advertises it's tight Automatic
Voltage Regulated to be between 114 - 126 Volts when the UPS is
drawing from the batteries (120 Volts +-5%). The Voltage didn't
even start rising from 88 Volts for 8 minutes & never got above
100 Volts until 20 minutes, so clearly the AVR in this UPS isn't
well designed for low Wattages of 100. This
UPS lasted 59:45 minutes under a 100 Watt load, which
is a lower load than most computers with a monitor. When tested
unplugged from the wall at 173 Watt load, this UPS dropped as low
as 98 Volts which is marginally acceptable & it went higher
within 3 minutes as the battery started to drain, so obviously there
is some kind of low quality crude Voltage regulation. This
UPS lasted 32 minutes under a 174 Watt load
which is more typical of the load that an average computer
& large monitor would be. That is substantially less than the
24-28 minute quote on the box for a desktop PC with a 21" monitor
& also less than the manual which states that this UPS should
power a 200 Watt load for 17 minutes. At 231 Watts load it went
as low as 100.3 Volts but within a minute the Voltage started going
higher. The AVR clearly works better under a heavier loads, but
Voltage dips under heavier loads, as was evident by a light bulb
that flickered. This UPS
lasted 23:50 minutes under a 236 Watt load which
is typical of the load that a more powerful tower PC & 19"
monitor might draw. When I loaded the UPS with various Wattage's
up to 365 & unplugged it from the wall, the UPS did handle the
load without immediately shutting off. This unit sells for
$200. CDN. at Future Shop & it is the minimum size I would recommend
for most modern computers with a monitor. It's not a great UPS,
especially for low Wattage loads (100 Watts) because of poor quality
Automatic Voltage Regulation, but it is marginally acceptable for
higher Wattage loads (150 - 230 Watts). I purchased this UPS for
150. CDN. at Costco in January 2004.
CYBER POWER 700AVR,
has a 700VA or 350 Watt rating. The spike filtering protection is
825 Joules & the maximum surge current is 36,000 Amps. It only
has 2 outlets that are battery protected (3 or 4 would have been
handier). This unit does not seem to have very good AVR (Automatic
Voltage Regulator) despite it's advertised claims. It mentions on
the box that it protects in brownout situations (under 112 Volts)
(which means that it should prop up the low line Voltage & bring
it back up near nominal 117 VAC levels) & overvoltage situations
(over 130 Volts). I tested brownout conditions with a stepping transformer
& this UPS did not kick in when it should & prop up the
Voltage until it got quite low (didn't cut in at 107.5 Volts, but
did prop up Voltage when the input was at 102.8 Volts) (it's suppose
to kick in when Voltage goes below 112 VAC). When I tested this
unit unplugged from the wall under a 100 Watt load, the
Voltage level dropped to about 88 Volts (unacceptable)
which isn't adequate in my opinion for many devices & certainly
not what I would have expected for a unit that advertises it's tight
Automatic Voltage Regulated to be between 114 - 126 Volts when the
UPS is drawing from the batteries (120 Volts +-5%). The Voltage
didn't even start rising from 88 Volts for 8 minutes & never
got above 100 Volts until 20 minutes, so clearly the AVR in this
UPS isn't well designed for low Wattages of 100. At 100 Watts load,
this UPS lasted 30:24 minutes (less than the manual claims). When
tested unplugged from the wall at 173 Watt load, this UPS dropped
as low as 98 Volts which is marginally acceptable & it went
higher within 3 minutes as the battery started to drain, so obviously
there is some kind of low quality crude Voltage regulation. This
UPS lasted only 12:34 minutes under a 173 Watt loadwhich
is more typical of the load that an average computer & large
monitor would be. That is substantially less than the 24-28 minute
quote on the box for a desktop PC with a 21" monitor &
also less than the manual which states that this UPS should power
a 200 Watt load for 17 minutes. At 231 Watts load it went as low
as 100.3 Volts but within a minute the Voltage started going higher.
The AVR clearly works better under a heavier loads, but Voltage
dips under heavier loads, as was evident by a light bulb that flickered.
This UPS lasted
only 8:00 minutes under a 231 Watt load (manual
claims 12 minutes under a 250 Watt load). When I loaded the UPS
with various Wattage's up to 365 & unplugged it from the wall,
the UPS did handle the load without immediately shutting off.
This unit sells for $200. CDN. at Future Shop & it is the minimum
size I would recommend for most modern computers with a monitor.
It's not a great UPS, especially for low Wattage loads (100 Watts)
because of poor quality Automatic Voltage Regulation, but it is
marginally acceptable for higher Wattage loads (150 - 230 Watts).
CYBER POWER 650SL,
has a 650VA or 350 Watt rating. The spike filtering protection is
only 585 Joules & the maximum surge current is 36,000 Amps.
This unit does not seem to have sufficient AVR (Automatic Voltage
Regulation) even though it mentions on the box that it protects
in brownout situations (which means that it would not prop up the
low line Voltage & bring it back up near nominal 117 VAC levels).
I simulated brownout conditions with a stepping transformer &
this UPS did not kick in & prop up the Voltage until it got
quite low. When I tested this unit unplugged from the wall under
a 100 Watt load, the Voltage level at times dropped as low as 102.6
Volts which is adequate in my opinion for many devices, but not
what I would consider tight Voltage Regulated. When tested at 173
Watt load this UPS dropped as low as 112.7 Volts but went higher
as the battery started to drain, so obviously there is some kind
of low to medium quality crude Voltage regulation. The Volt &
Watt meters verified this, as did the light bulb which briefly dimmed
(almost a flicker) frequently. The box says that the output Voltage
when running on the battery should be 120 Volts +-5% (which is 114
- 126 Volts), but it didn't even come close to the specs. This UPS
lasted 25:20 minutes under a 100 Watt load, but would last far less
under the load of most computers with a monitor. This
UPS lasted only 9:20 minutes under a 173 Watt loadwhich
is more typical of the load that an average computer & monitor
would be. That is substantial less than the 14-18 minute quote on
the box for a desktop PC with a 21" monitor. A major shortcoming
was evident when I loaded this UPS with 225 Watts & unplugged
it from the wall, the UPS did not handle the load, it immediately
shut off. In my
opinion, a UPS that is rated to be able to handle a 350 Watt load
during a power outage, should not immediately shut down when it
only has a 225 Watt load during a power outage with a fully charged
battery. If that is all this UPS can do under new
charged conditions, what's it's performance level going to be like
in a few years as the battery ages? This unit sells for $150. CDN.
at Future Shop, but I do not recommend it.
BELKIN 520VA
(model F6C520-SER-LC, or P56373-A, or BEK-65-0073)
has a 520VA or 312 Watt rating. This unit is not part of Belkin's
better line called "Gold Series", so this unit does not
claim to have AVR (Automatic Voltage Regulation), which means that
in a brown-out situation (low line Voltage) it would not prop up
the Voltage & bring it back up near nominal 117 VAC levels.
When I tested this unit fully charged & unplugged from the wall
under a 100 Watt load, the Voltage level at times dropped as low
as 91.5 Volts which is unacceptable in my opinion, though many computer
power supplies might still be able to function properly at this
low Voltage level. When tested at 173 Watt load this UPS dropped
as low as 104.7 Volts but went higher as the battery started to
drain, so obviously there is some kind of crude Voltage regulation.
The manufacture's stated operating range is 93 to 135 Volts. The
spike filtering protection is only 320 Joules & the high frequency
ENI/RFI filter is 10 dB at 0.15 MHz or 50 dB at 30 MHz. This UPS
lasted 18:45 minutes under a 100 Watt load, but would last far less
under the load of most computers with a monitor. This
UPS lasted only 6:50 minutes under a 173 Watt load.
The box indicates that this UPS will provide 28 minutes of back-up
power, but it doesn't say under how much load & since even the
simplest computer with a small monitor will draw more than 100 Watts,
the manufacturer's claim of 28 minutes is clearly deceptive &
nowhere near what you will actually get. The manual says this UPS
will last 5-28 minutes with a PC computer & a 15" monitor
plugged into it. When I loaded the UPS with 225 Watts & unplugged
it from the wall, the UPS did handle the load without immediately
shutting off. This UPS was on sale at Compusmart for $70. CDN (regularly
$100. CDN). I do not recommend this unit for a computer & monitor
as it is too small.
See also INVERTERS that create
AC Voltage for household appliances from a battery.
By Doug Hembruff.
Last updated July 5, 2005
|